Current Listing Practices

Presently, the vast majority of homes for sale are publicly advertised online and through Multiple Listing Services (MLS). These databases are utilized by real estate brokers to share property information widely, ensuring broad visibility for sellers and extensive options for buyers.

Brokerages Seek Private Listing Flexibility

Some real estate brokerages are advocating for greater flexibility to share listings privately with their own agents and clients before making them publicly available on the MLS. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) is reportedly considering a rule change this month that could accommodate this shift. Proponents of private listings argue that it offers sellers more control over when and how their properties are advertised.

Arguments for Private Listings

Advocates for private listings suggest that the current system can negatively affect home values by publicly revealing information such as price reductions and the amount of time a property has been on the market. They contend that allowing pre-market sharing within a brokerage can lead to better outcomes for sellers.

Concerns About Market Access and Transparency

Conversely, real estate experts and consumer advocates express concerns that a move towards private listing networks could restrict buyers' access to the already limited housing supply. They also caution that limiting a property's exposure to the broader market might prevent sellers from achieving the highest possible sale price. Research indicates that homes sold outside the MLS tend to sell for less than comparable properties listed publicly.

Industry Perspectives on Private Listings

Critics of private listing networks argue that they create a less transparent marketplace, potentially benefiting individual brokerages by requiring buyers to work with them to access certain listings. In contrast, brokerages supporting private listings cite internal research suggesting that homes "pre-marketed" within their network can achieve a higher sale price.

Industry Under Scrutiny

The discussion surrounding private listings occurs in the wake of a significant legal settlement involving the National Association of Realtors. This settlement has brought increased scrutiny to the industry's rules and practices, with potential far-reaching consequences for consumers and the future of real estate transactions.

‍