Property taxes are becoming an increasingly significant financial burden for many homeowners across the United States, with some of the steepest increases in the country occurring in Florida. According to recent data from Redfin, property tax payments in some major metro areas have risen dramatically since the onset of the pandemic. Rising home values, coupled with an influx of new residents and frequent natural disasters, have contributed to escalating tax rates. For homeowners and prospective buyers alike, understanding these trends is essential.

Why Are Property Taxes Rising?

Several factors have driven the recent surge in property taxes across U.S. metro areas. The rapid increase in home values during the pandemic, combined with a growing population and natural disaster resilience funding, has forced many local governments to adjust property tax rates. Below are the primary reasons fueling this trend:

1. Rising Home Values

The pandemic spurred a housing boom in many states, with Florida becoming a hotspot for out-of-state buyers seeking relatively affordable homes and a favorable tax environment. However, this surge in demand led to increased home values, which, in turn, resulted in higher assessed property values. Higher assessed values mean higher tax bills, making it increasingly difficult for local residents to afford homeownership.

2. Impact of Natural Disasters

Florida’s vulnerability to hurricanes and other natural disasters has further contributed to property tax increases. To support climate resilience projects and repair infrastructure, local governments have had to adjust tax rates. In states like Florida and Texas, which do not collect state income tax, property taxes become a crucial source of funding for essential services, including disaster preparedness.

3. Population Growth and Demand for Public Services

Florida’s growing population has added pressure on infrastructure and public services, driving up costs. With increased demand for schools, roads, and emergency services, municipalities have found it necessary to increase property taxes to cover the rising costs, especially given inflation’s impact on these expenditures.

Property Tax Increases: Which Areas Are Hit Hardest?

Redfin’s analysis of the 50 largest metro areas in the U.S. highlights significant increases in property tax payments, particularly in Indianapolis, Atlanta, and three of Florida’s biggest metro areas: Miami, Tampa, and Jacksonville. Below are some of the most notable examples:

• Indianapolis: Property taxes in Indianapolis have seen the largest increase, with homeowners now paying 66.7% more than they did in 2019. The median monthly property tax payment has risen to $205.
• Atlanta: Following close behind, Atlanta has experienced a 65.8% increase, with average monthly property taxes now at $239.
• Florida Metros: Miami, Tampa, and Jacksonville have seen respective increases of 48.1%, 56.7%, and 59.6% since 2019. In Miami, the median monthly property tax is now $367, making homeownership less affordable for local residents as well as newcomers.

These increases highlight the ongoing affordability challenges in these areas, where rising property taxes add to the burden of already-high home prices and insurance costs.

Changing Homebuyer Demand in Disaster-Prone Areas

The rising costs of property ownership, particularly in areas frequently hit by natural disasters, have begun to impact homebuyer demand. According to a Redfin-Ipsos survey, many young buyers are reconsidering Florida as a viable option due to concerns about natural disasters and the associated financial risks. In 2023, migration to high-risk areas in Florida slowed, with some people choosing to settle in regions less prone to climate-related risks.

High-profile hurricanes, such as Hurricane Helene, have raised awareness among Gen Z and millennial homebuyers, leading many to seek homes outside of Florida’s high-risk zones. Nearly one-third of young adults surveyed reported that they are reconsidering their choice of location after seeing the damage caused by recent hurricanes. Additionally, a significant portion of Florida residents (21%) are considering relocating in part due to high property taxes and climate concerns.

Metro-Level Insights: The U.S. Property Tax Landscape

While Florida has seen some of the highest property tax increases, other regions across the U.S. also face steep property tax rates and payments. Redfin’s research provides a breakdown of property tax levels across major metro areas:

• High Tax Burdens in New York and New Jersey: Nassau County, NY, leads the nation with a median monthly property tax of $905. Newark, NJ ($848) and New York City ($821) are also among the highest. This is due to a combination of high effective tax rates and elevated home values.
• Lowest Monthly Property Taxes in the Sun Belt: In areas like Phoenix ($151), Nashville ($152), and Charlotte, NC ($157), monthly property tax bills are significantly lower, largely due to lower effective tax rates and more affordable home prices.
• Texas Leads in Effective Tax Rates: Texas cities have some of the highest effective property tax rates, with Austin leading at 1.8%. Other Texas cities, including San Antonio and Houston, follow close behind at 1.7%.

Property Taxes as a Share of Monthly Income

For many homeowners, property taxes are a substantial part of their monthly expenses. New York buyers allocate the highest share of income to property taxes, with an average of 10% of monthly income going toward these payments. Other high-tax metros, like Newark and Austin, see similar shares. On the other end, buyers in Nashville, Phoenix, and Las Vegas spend only 2-3% of their income on property taxes, making these areas comparatively affordable.

In Texas, property taxes make up a significant 20% of the typical housing bill in cities like Austin and Houston, reflecting the high rates and home values in these areas. In contrast, areas like Nashville and Phoenix see property taxes making up only about 5% of housing costs, easing the financial burden for local homeowners.

Rising Property Taxes: The Upside for Communities

While rising property taxes may strain homeowners' budgets, they also offer benefits for communities. These funds are typically reinvested in local amenities, infrastructure, and public services. Improved parks, schools, and other community resources can enhance property values and make neighborhoods more attractive. Higher property taxes can also help curb real estate speculation, encouraging long-term homeownership and stabilizing communities.

Conclusion

The rapid rise in property taxes across many U.S. metro areas is a pressing concern for homeowners, especially in high-growth, high-demand regions like Florida. As property values and the cost of government services increase, local governments may continue to adjust tax rates to fund essential services and disaster resilience projects. Prospective buyers and current homeowners alike should be aware of these trends and consider how property taxes will impact their financial plans in the years to come.

‍